Postmodernism
thought rotates around the rejection of hard classifications and the acceptance
of the view of the human life as an experience that is filled with
individuality and contradictions. As Dr.
Mahnke said, once at the beginning of our time together, and once at the end; "So
many people will try to get you to skip over the question and go straight to
the answer, and I will tell you, never do this. Always ask the question." For
postmodern thinkers, there really is no "right answer". There are simply too
many variables within the human experience to allow there to be; i.e. society's
values, religion, cultural influences, and personal interaction within the
aforementioned realms. Postmodernism is the push away from the traditional, old
world values and into the growing conscious of society. It began in the 1870's
as a way to interpret life through art, in the early 1900's became a philosophy
on living and today has become a way of living that impacts our laws, the
church, art, and personal relationships.
Stare decisis means
"to stand by decisions and not disturb the undisturbed." (Adeleye, 371)
With modernism thought, the judicial system calls upon precedent set by
forefathers using "nuclear family values" which don't always translate into today's
societal moral code. With postmodern thought, much of the traditional societal
moral code is being given a second look. Stare decisis has become much less of
a 'means to an end' and more of a way to critically view the strengths and
weaknesses of prior judicial decisions. This has caused some of the most heated
political controversies to remain grey areas (for example, abortion and gay
marriage), forcing legal doctrine to include new standards for law making, such
as moral law. (According to the online free legal dictionary, moral law is
defined as "rules of behavior an
individual or a group may follow out of personal conscience and that are not
necessarily part of legislated law in the United States".)
To illustrate post modernism in the church, focusing
strictly on the Lutheran church, one must only look to the recent and ongoing
chasm between the beliefs of the Missouri Synod (LCMS) and Evangelical Lutheran
(ELCA) churches. While LCMS remains the
traditional Lutheran church, ELCA grows rapidly as a favorite within the United
States of America. With a shared fundamental religion, yet visions of the
church that so obviously differ, these two Lutheran churches can really only be
called third-cousins. The LCMS uses their own version of Stare decisis by
focusing on the scripture as a literal text, while the ECLA leaves room for the
grey areas that the postmodernism movement is fond of.
"The
[difference between the churches, on the] doctrine and authority of Scripture.
The LCMS believes that the Bible is without error in all that it says. The ELCA
avoids making such statements, holding that Scripture is not necessarily always
accurate on such matters as history and science. Differences between the LCMS
and the ELCA on the authority of Scripture also help to explain why the ELCA
ordains women to the pastoral office, while the LCMS does not (based on 1 Cor
14:33-36 and 1Tim 2:11-14). Similarly, on the basis of what Scripture clearly
teaches (Rom 1:18-28; 1 Cor 6:9), the LCMS position on homosexual behavior is
unequivocal: homosexual behavior is contrary to God's will, while the ELCA has
declared that it lacks a consensus regarding what Scripture teaches about
homosexual activity. Consequently, those who disagree with one another in the
ELCA have been called to respect the 'bound conscience' of the others. The ELCA
has also determined to allow the ordination of practicing homosexuals as long
as they are in a life-long, committed relationship." (lcms.org)
Postmodernism
in the church is often voiced in the discussions pertaining to the acceptance
that Jesus provides all of God's children (Justification Through Faith), which
inhibits either faction from completely rejecting the other.
It was with the postmodernism movement, that recent
art began to be legitimatized as more than just a pretty picture. The
postmodernism movement is characterized, in part, by a move towards
individuality and a rejection of cultural norms. Similarly, Art is often
characterized as a display of individual expression. Thus, the attention to the personal
expression of the art, combined with the acceptance of individuality and
personal convictions that the postmodernism movement created, allowed scholars
to recognize art as a way of knowing yourself, and thus the world around you. "The
arts must be taken no less seriously than the sciences as modes of discovery,
creation, and enlargement of knowledge in the broad sense of advancement of the
understanding." (Graham, pg 44)
The fundamentals in our lives (law, religion, and
our way of viewing the world), through postmodernism have changed dramatically.
It is only logical that our personal relationships follow suit. If not in the
most obvious of ways (civil unions
versus marriage in the courtroom, our choice in how we interpret an age old
text, whether or not we take something at face value or choose to favor
introspection and look for the answers to the truly difficult questions, etc),
then in the more subtle interactions we have with the world. There are, and
have always been, people in the world who are self-involved without a care to
their fellow man. This, to me, is the antithesis of postmodernism.
Postmodernism teaches that if you read between the lines, you can discover that,
in fact, the issues are personal. These issues can range from an environment
that is deteriorating, to electing a president. Sure, you can relate these two
topics on a political level, but it is when they relate to your own life; when
you can relate to the world with a more sophisticated thought process (again,
always ask the question), that the issues become more about ethics and our
ability to see in more than just black and white and interpret the grey areas. With
this thought process we become compassionate beings who are able to create
convictions based on purely our own judgment.
I was raised by a fairly young mother, and without
knowing it I was raised in a postmodern thinking household. I was instilled with
the belief that there is a difference between accountability and culpability;
being responsible for your own thoughts, emotions, motives and beliefs, instead
of blindly believing what is right and wrong, then applying it to other people.
It seems to me, if there ever was a bumper sticker for the postmodernist, it
should read "I'll get back to you in three days; I need to figure out how I
feel and what I think."
The
phrase given, "This sentence
serves no logical purpose," exemplifies postmodernism to a "T". When first
looking at it, one might just accept that fact that this phrase is ridiculous.
"How could I compare this to anything of relevance!?" one might ask. Well, in
fact it is perfect in illustrating the void that postmodernism fills by
inquiring about information that one finds 'in-between the lines'. First, one
might look at context. Our prompt asks us to consider the phrase within the
context of postmodernism. I choose to interpret this as "consider the following
phrase using a postmodernism mindset". I'm still within the context of the
prompt; I'm just going beyond face value.
Next, I try to think of the sentence as a
piece of the whole (still using my postmodernism mindset). Imagine if your desk
chair was missing a wheel, one day someone who had never seen a desk chair before,
finds it. What would they do with that wheel? I would most likely throw it out.
It's only once I would see the whole chair together that insight would come.
Thus, I've left answering the prompt until the end of my paper in attempts to
produce insight. Perhaps that was the reason that the particular phrase was
given. It was defiantly not a phrase that we could just skip through the
thought process with and come out with a legitimate answer. Instead, I was
forced to ponder and consider the context and truly learn what a postmodernism
mindset is.
As a result, I think the phrase does exactly
what it claims without context; serves no purpose. However, in the context of
the paper, I can see that the phrase was used in a rational (albeit
round-a-bout) way, making it logical.
According to vunom.com
(a postmodern artist resource), "Whereas Modernism is
often associated with identity, unity, authority, and certainty, Postmodernism
is often associated with difference, plurality, alterity, and skepticism." To
simplify, postmodernism is about asking the question and following the path on
which it lead.
Works Cited:
Contrast, and court decisions in some civil law
jurisdictions (most prominently France). "Stare decisis - Wikipedia, the
free encyclopedia." Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. N.p., n.d.
Web. 20 Sept. 2010. <http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stare_decisis>.
Adeleye, Gabriel et al. World
Dictionary of Foreign Expressions: a Resource for Readers and Writers,
page 371 (1999)
lightman. "A LCMS Pastor's Appeal to the ELCA." Latest
Articles. N.p., n.d. Web. 20 Sept. 2010.
<http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/religion/2275682/posts>.
"ELCA | The Lutheran Church - Missouri Synod." The
Lutheran Church - Missouri Synod - . N.p., n.d. Web. 20 Sept. 2010.
<http://www.lcms.org/pages/internal.asp?NavID=2146>.
" Social Issues - Evangelical Lutheran Church in
America." Home - Evangelical Lutheran Church in America. N.p., n.d.
Web. 20 Sept. 2010.
<http://www.elca.org/What-We-Believe/Social-Issues.aspx>.
Graham, Gordon. Philosophy
of the Arts: An Introduction to Aesthetic, 3rd Edition (2005). 25 Sep. 2010
"Postmodernism | Vunom." Vunom art resources
for artists. N.p., n.d. Web. 25 Sept. 2010.
<http://vunom.com/postmodernism/>.
Recent Comments