Chapter 2 of our Project Report is a literature review. Since I just finished chapter 2 a couple days ago, it's still pretty fresh in my mind and is asking to be the subject of a blog post.
First of all, allow me to rant a little (prospective Honors students, skip this paragraph). I understand the purpose and value of a literature review. If you're going to be studying anything, it makes sense that it would be helpful to read about the studies already done on the subject. What I
don't like is citing literature reviews in a literature review. Many of the journal articles I used were not necessarily dedicated literature reviews, but they didn't seem to do much more than cite many other sources. What I'm trying to say here is that I really appreciate when people do their own work and offer
new material to the rest of the world. Again, I realize the value of having the ability to use the work of someone else, but some of the articles that I read seemed to be compilations of what others have said with nothing new being given by the author. In those cases, I might as well just go read the original works. So when we use journal articles like this in a literature review, we're almost reviewing a review. I managed to only do it once, but I easily could have had many of my references be citations of citations. Of course, the other component that made writing this chapter awkward and difficult is the fact that none of us are really educated or informed in our social issues (such as parochial elementary schools in an urban setting, in my case). That couples with the fact that we didn't have enough time to actually read any of our journal articles or books in their entirety. This means that some of the quotes or ideas we took from them were probably taken out of context. All in all, I feel like this exercise was assigned in the mentality that "these aren't going to be the best literature reviews you could write, and this isn't really the best method for writing a literature review, but at least it introduces you to the practice." That being said, I was ranting about these very things to a graduate student (who's even studying education) who said that she had written many such papers and never really read through the journal articles either. She also complained about how many of them were basically rehashes of other people's work. I want my work and learning to be genuine, not just doing no more than I have to to meet assignment requirements. Note: This is not a request for more difficult homework! I am just a humble freshman, after all.
So although I don't believe that my chapter 2 is as good as it could be for the reasons I just gave, I'll share it with you
here anyway.
We were told to write our literature review in such a way that we began broadly and narrowed in on our specific issue. Although I feel like this should've been presented to us as a helpful hint rather than an unbreakable rule, I did it for the sake of following instructions. Because my study is really on the challenges faced by a parochial elementary school, specifically one in an urban setting, I would've rather liked to focus on that area the entire time. Instead, I began by including issues faced by elementary schools in general, then narrowed in to issues faced by urban elementary schools, and finally narrowed in again to add the issues included with the parochial component. I think that structure worked out fairly well.
At the elementary school level, I chose to address three issues: community involvement, technology integration, and school safety. For schools in urban settings, I focused on the problems of high student mobility and lack of leadership. And the challenges I included for parochial schools were related to federal aid and maintaining balance of faith-based and "secular" education (although I'm still trying to decide whether there is such a thing as "secular" education).
Sometime toward the end of writing chapter 2, it finally clicked in me that I could actually work to solve these problems in some ways at Trinity First Lutheran School. If nothing else, simply observing the degree to which these issues exist there and seeing how the school reacts to them will help me better understand the topic.